The Battle of the Rohirrim Is Superior, However Nonetheless Barely Underwhelming

Once you sit down to observe The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Rohirrim there’s no mistake it’s a Lord of the Rings film. The music, the cinematography, the voiceover, every part about it was fastidiously and neatly designed to slot in seamlessly with the blockbuster, Oscar-winning live-action films we all know and love. And that nostalgia solely helps amp up the story which is already slightly sweeping and epic.

What occurs, although, is you start to query why you’re watching this in any respect. In a medium the place something is feasible, set in a world with wizards, dragons, and immortality, is animation including something to this story? Is it displaying one thing that you simply’d by no means see in live-action? And the reply, for The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Rohirrim, is mainly that it isn’t. It’s a disconnect that holds an excellent movie again from being the basic its franchise calls for.

Directed by Kenji Kamiyama, from a script by Jeffrey Addiss, Will Matthews, Phoebe Gittins, and Arty Papageorgio, The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Rohirrim is set about 200 years before the events of The Hobbit. It focuses on the folks of Rohan, primarily the household of King Helm Hammerhand (Brian Cox), a powerful, well-liked ruler. When the king mistakenly kills a rival by way of, the rival’s son Wulf (Luke Pasqualino) vows revenge, setting off a series response that may change Rohan perpetually.

Central to the story is Hera (Gaia Smart), the lone daughter of the king who’s beloved by all, but additionally underestimated. As her father and brothers (Hama and Haleth) take care of Wulf and his armies, it’s Hera who holds the Rohan collectively, particularly once they’re pressured into the stronghold we all know as Helm’s Deep. It’s not known as that but although and, because you simply learn the king’s title, you possibly can most likely get a way of why it’s known as that and the place the story goes.

The Battle of the Rohirrim has a dynamite, thrilling, and sweeping first act in addition to a jaw-dropping, superior third act. It’s an enormous story and so, a lot occurs in it you frankly can’t consider they have been in a position to stuff all of it into one film. The issue, nevertheless, is the center of the movie the place issues drag significantly. When Hera and the Rohan discover themselves caught in Helm’s Deep, the movie slows all the way down to a screeching halt. In a means, that change of tempo mirrors the story of the movie, besides, it may be a serious slog. Fortunately, when it picks up once more, the finale roughly makes up for it.

The pacing points are additionally barely helped by the very fact The Battle of the Rohirrim seems to be beautiful. Within the movie’s opening second, you watch what you consider is actuality and it’s solely when an enormous eagle flies into the body that you simply notice it’s animated. That degree of high quality is there all through, with each character, creature, vista, and constructing drawn to look as stuffed with life as the true factor, if no more so. Even when the film is dragging, enjoyment might be down at simply marveling on the look. The Battle of the Rohirrim set the bar of magnificence excessive, which makes its violence and motion that rather more impactful.

Nevertheless, as lovely because the movie seems to be, there’s not often a second watching the place you possibly can’t image the identical factor in live-action. That shouldn’t be a prerequisite for an anime like this, particularly one which’s so gorgeously crafted, however as a result of it’s Lord of the Rings and since Peter Jackson was in a position to do such beautiful issues in these films, it simply hangs over this one like a cloud. You retain hoping for the movie to justify itself past simply the good characters, visuals, and story, however it very not often does. Even when the story hits enormous emotional beats and the stakes change into literal life or demise, it’s solely engaged on that one degree.

Which needs to be sufficient, proper? Nice characters, visuals, story, and stakes needs to be sufficient for a film to be an entire residence run. The Battle of the Rohirrim even begins to tie into the Lord of the Rings films in methods that may delight followers. However, even at its finest, you simply can’t assist however assume this whole film ought to have a greater motive for current slightly than solely being a stable film. And it doesn’t. Faults and all, it’s actually extra full and satisfying than The Hobbit films, however it will probably’t fairly dwell as much as its predecessors or many of the different unbelievable animated movies launched this yr. It’s nonetheless superior although and if you’re a Lord of the Rings fan, you’ll get pleasure from it. However simply go in with barely tempered expectations.

The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Rohirrim opens Friday.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and every part it is advisable to learn about the way forward for Doctor Who.